Hanging pictures on walls cannot bring change: Jannatul Mawa

The photographer Jannatul Mawa on Close Distance, which seated domestic workers beside their employers, the recognition of domestic workers in labour law, and what still holds women photographers back.

Written by

in

Education

Jannatul Mawa is a photographer based in Dhaka. She teaches photography at the Pathshala South Asian Media Institute, where she also studied. Before she picked up a camera she spent years as a social and gender rights activist, and she began her photographic career with UNICEF. In her series Close Distance, middle-class women in Dhaka sit on the drawing-room sofa beside their domestic workers; Finding Neverland follows her daughter’s childhood. According to Pathshala, her work has been shown at Chobi Mela, the Dhaka Art Summit, the Delhi Photo Festival and Photoquai 2015 in Paris, among other exhibitions, and published in Le Monde and The Guardian. On 8 November she emailed BD Global Times written answers, in English, to eight questions on photography, class and gender. Her answers appear below in full and in her own words.

It is the activist or political worker, not the photographer, who can bring a struggle to its goal. Photography can only act as the catalyst.

Jannatul Mawa

Q: You came to photography after years as a social and gender activist, and you began your photographic career with UNICEF. What drew you from activism to the camera, and what can a photograph do that activism could not?

A: There is no alternative to working actively in the struggle against discrimination. My family didn’t want me in politics, so once I joined student politics, I stopped relying on them entirely for support. I studied, took on different jobs to support myself, and kept up the politics.

My work, at one point, led me to the villages for a long stretch. I was working on preventing violence against women, while continuing to work within our own political platform. It struck me then that I had worked under others for my bread and butter long enough. I wanted to choose a medium of my own and build my practice, one that would also serve the political struggle. That is how I picked up photography and began to wield its powerful language as a tool.

However, I remain firm in the position that a political worker or activist plays a more direct role than a photographer in reaching the goal. Today, it is impossible to manifest change by merely printing pictures and hanging them on the walls. Beyond documenting, photographers must work on the streets with the people affected, marching for their demands and rights. It is the activist or political worker, not the photographer, who can bring a struggle to its goal. Photography can only act as the catalyst.

To change this unequal world, there is no substitute for full-time politics. I couldn’t do it myself owing to my own limitations. But alongside freelance photography, I have been working as a political worker.

Q: In Close Distance, you asked middle-class women to sit beside their domestic workers on the drawing-room sofa, a sofa the worker dusts every day but, as you have put it, is not expected to sit on. How did the families respond when you asked, and what happened in the room when the photographs were taken?

A: Some of the homeowner women in the photographs, the ones who agreed to be photographed, I already knew. Others I reached through references. I should say that although they are indirect partners in sustaining this inequality, they believe it is inhuman for people to be divided this way. They see change as reasonable, and the due value of labour as essential. During the shoot, they were quite relaxed and natural.

The domestic workers, on the other hand, seemed unprepared and embarrassed. Their hesitation about sitting beside the “lady of the house” on the sofa is evident in the photographs. Many did not sit on the sofa at all and instead sat on the floor. Some stood behind it, behind her. Some, sitting side by side with her for the first time, covered their faces in embarrassment. One of them had said, “I have a lot more work to do. Madam took her time getting dressed up, but I, the dasi (maid) am supposed to be photographed looking pitiful, as the dasi?”

I loved the sense of dignity in the way she spoke. Her words echoed the truth that the lady of the house depends on her, not the other way round. Interestingly, that connotation is distinctly visible in her photograph too.

Q: Your work has been exhibited from Dhaka to Paris and published in Le Monde and The Guardian. How have audiences at home responded to Close Distance, compared with audiences abroad?

A: Slavery and colonial rule began on the other side of the world, yet those nations now speak of, and practise, sensitivity to human and labour rights at home. To audiences abroad, this exhibition is a record of a distant social reality. Their response is mostly humane and structural; they see it as the problem of structural and class inequality in a developing country.

At home, wherever it has been shown, I found viewers jolted upon first sight. Aware citizens and young people appeared deeply affected by the photographs. Many were led to re-examine their own behaviour, and it has stirred a wish for positive change.

Q: This year, Bangladesh’s labour law recognised domestic workers as workers for the first time. Can a change in the law reach inside the home, and what, if anything, has changed for domestic workers since you made Close Distance?

A: Photography alone cannot change domestic workers’ lives. It can help move sensitive people, make them concerned, and hold them accountable.

The affluent section of society that extracts the services of domestic workers for peanuts does so by consciously exploiting working people’s precarity. I doubt this privileged class possesses the rational and humane predisposition or culture that would make them give up that stream of cheap labour and instead grant a minimum wage, fixed hours, leaves, and social recognition for the work.

Change in the lives of working people, domestic workers included, is possible only when we join the struggle for their rights. That is why I have involved myself in the domestic workers’ movement.

Yes, domestic workers have been brought under Bangladesh’s labour law, but in practice most of their rights remain marked by uncertainty. Clear provisions and effective enforcement are missing on the basics: working hours, wages, leave, legal protection, compensation for workplace accidents. Unless proper rules are framed in line with the 2015 Domestic Workers Protection and Welfare Policy, the benefits of the 2026 amended labour law will not materialize.

Only once specific rules are implemented and enforced, domestic work will be recognised as labour, as part of the labour sector. It will also establish socially that this is not an odd job, and affirm its dignified standing.

What is sad is that most domestic workers don’t even know they have been recognised as workers. The government, particularly the Ministry of Labour, must work to communicate this information through different media. Those working on domestic workers’ rights, too, need to provide much stronger support so that workers can come together and form their unions.

Q: Your work often turns to people society prefers not to see: domestic workers, and the children of Geneva Camp who work in the meat trade instead of going to school. How do you make sure the people you photograph keep their dignity and have a say in how they are shown?

A: Protecting people’s dignity and respecting their own views is the most important foundation of my work. Whoever I photograph, and marginalised and deprived people especially, I try to hold to ethics and sensitivity. Before taking pictures, I explain clearly to them, or to their guardians if they are children, why the pictures are being taken and where they will be used. If they object to being photographed, or to a picture being published in a particular situation, that decision is respected completely.

Even so, it is a delicate matter. Even with consent, can I truly guarantee dignity from their point of view?

But as an activist, a political worker, my intention is clear. In the struggle for rights, and for a classless society free of discrimination, photography is a powerful language for me. When centering the lens on the working class straining under capitalism, or marginal communities denied their rights, I maintain the conscious effort to not curate them as mere “victims” or passive objects of pity. I strive to translate their fight, awarding agency, so that the message of their political struggle can carry through to the viewer.

In many cases, I work incorporating their perspectives much more directly. Recently, while working on the Birangonas (war heroines and survivors of the 1971 war), I asked them how they would prefer to be seen, and photographed them accordingly under the given direction.

Q: Finding Neverland turned the camera on your own family and your daughter’s childhood. How different is it to photograph someone you love?

A: Finding Neverland is a story drawn straight from my life, centring on my daughter. Because of my job at the time, we lived in a quiet little town. Her childhood was spent there, close to nature, without the complications of a capital or a megacity. When we came back to Dhaka, it took her years to adjust to the city. We had always hoped to one day return to the small town we left our hearts in, but the realities of life didn’t let us.

Making a photo story about someone you love is comparatively easy, I’d say. It is comfortable and filled with joy. All the variable elements are in your control. Photographing strangers, or people far from you in terms of relational proximity, is much harder and more complex. However skilled your communication, the result may not turn out the way you expect. That is a challenge.

But when you are the mother, your child loves and trusts you; the result naturally is likely to go your way. You have already read them. You understand them, and so it is easier to translate them, so to speak. Yet even then, when your loved ones are older, bearing unique personalities, the story may not emerge the way you set out to render it.

Still, I thoroughly enjoy the challenge of photographing strangers. It requires of you skills that extend well beyond photography. You need to know the subject well before you go. You must develop an instinct for the person’s temperament. You have to build trust in a very short time. All of this sharpens your communication. Only then, I think, can you give them your full attention and draw out different, deep, delicate expressions.

Q: You have taught at Pathshala for many years, and you have spoken about the pressure from family and the scepticism that women photographers face. What has changed for the young women you teach, and what still holds them back?

A: More girls enrol than before, but the number is still far from ideal. In a patriarchal society, women and men grow up differently, and are thus conditioned to see society, politics and the economy differently. That is exactly why a medium this powerful needs many more women.

Photography as a hobby is one thing. As a profession, it is challenging for women and men alike, and for women it is twice as hard. Many who have worked for years have given up and dropped out. There are specific reasons why the women photographers who should have risen have not.

In Bangladesh, photography is still considered an uncertain or precarious profession. A career takes time, money, dedication, and long-term commitment. Many families think it risky, especially with no assured income. For women, that uncertainty comes with social expectations, family pressure, and concerns about personal safety.

In Bangladeshi society, more than competence in their work, doubt and taboo persist around women photographers’ professional presence and mobility. The lack of social safety and freedom to move discourages them further in a country where women are not safe anywhere, day or night. The structural struggle for fair pay in freelance and commercial photography, for professional survival, is also acute.

Money is a barrier. Photography requires expensive equipment and travel, and enough financial independence to sustain long-term projects. So even with talent, ability, and strong will, women from middle- and low-income families struggle hard to stay. Most are eventually disillusioned and go back.

There is a glaring gap between women photographers’ visibility and their capacity to sustain a career. Many women now show their work on social media. But we need to ask how many of them are able to continue working long-term, build independent documentary projects, find funding, and win recognition from major institutions. Being visible as a photographer and sustaining photography as a profession are two very different things.

So I think it isn’t enough to encourage more women into photography. We have to build the material reality for them to work safely, acquire financial support, take on long-term projects, find mentorship, and earn institutional recognition.

Q: What are you working on now, and is there a story you have long wanted to photograph but have not yet?

A: I am currently working on a book of research and photographs of places that mattered at different points in the life and work of Kazi Nazrul Islam, Bangladesh’s national poet. Separately, I am also researching the work of Bangladesh’s first professional woman photographer.

In 2014, I began working on the Birangonas of Bangladesh. For various reasons, I couldn’t finish. Many of them have since passed away. This year, at last, I have taken the work up again.


About the interviewee: Jannatul Mawa is a photographer based in Dhaka and a teacher at the Pathshala South Asian Media Institute. Before turning to photography she was a social and gender rights activist; she began her photographic career with UNICEF. Her best-known work includes Close Distance and Finding Neverland.

বাংলায় মূল প্রতিবেদন পড়ুন · Read the original Bengali report

More in English

English edition