The 30-year Ganges water-sharing treaty with India expires on December 12. Only a few weeks remain, but the two countries have yet to finalize a schedule for formal talks on renewing or replacing it.
Amid the uncertainty, Bangladesh has pressed for a guarantee clause in the next agreement that would legally ensure a minimum supply of water during the dry season under any circumstances.
Diplomatic efforts and the current situation
Sources at the Foreign Ministry and Water Resources Ministry said Dhaka formed a high-level technical committee in June to prepare for renewal. It then wrote to India in August and again this November, urging talks to begin soon.
Water Resources Minister Shahiduddin Chowdhury Annie recently told an event that the government was working to complete the renewal before December 12. “Our main priority will be to restore a guarantee clause like the one in the 1977 agreement,” he said.
Sources at the Joint Rivers Commission (JRC) said regular technical contacts were continuing. However, a major decision such as renewing the treaty requires agreement at the highest political level in both countries. Uncertainty remains because Delhi has yet to announce a date for formal talks.
What Bangladesh wants
Under the current treaty, signed on December 12, 1996, Ganges water at Farakka is shared in 10-day cycles from January 1 to May 31 each year. But experience over the past 30 years has shown that Bangladesh loses its fair share when upstream flows fall. Bangladesh therefore wants several fundamental changes rather than a renewal on identical terms.
A guarantee clause, or assurance of minimum water supplies: The five-year agreement signed in 1977 included a provision guaranteeing Bangladesh at least 80 percent of its allocated share even if upstream flows fell unusually low. That safeguard was omitted from the 1996 treaty. Bangladesh now wants it restored.
Accounting for upstream water withdrawals: River experts say India’s construction of about 29 dams and hydropower projects upstream on the Ganges has reduced flows at Farakka. Bangladesh, downstream, is feeling the effects.
Year-round, basin-wide management: Experts have called for a framework that covers year-round flows, sediment management and protection of the Sundarbans’ biodiversity, with Nepal included in basin-wide cooperation. This would replace an approach limited to sharing water during the five dry-season months.
Dispute resolution: No previous agreement has provided for independent arbitration to resolve disagreements over water sharing. There have been calls to include such a mechanism in the new treaty.
Experts recommend an interim renewal
Analysts believe the current diplomatic chill between the two countries and domestic politics in West Bengal make it difficult to sign a comprehensive new treaty in so little time.
Manjur Ahmed Chowdhury, an environmentalist and former chairman of the National River Conservation Commission, told a news outlet: “Renewing the current treaty unchanged for another 30 years could harm Bangladesh in the long term. But having no treaty would be even more dangerous. So the treaty should be renewed on an interim basis for at least three to five years before December 12, allowing time to prepare a comprehensive new agreement that protects Bangladesh’s interests.”
Those involved say that, without a treaty or interim understanding by December 12, India would no longer have any legal obligation to release water from Farakka during the dry season. This would put the agriculture, irrigation and environment on which more than 5 crore people depend across a third of the country’s southwestern region at grave risk.
বাংলায় মূল প্রতিবেদন পড়ুন · Read the original Bengali report