Even if Netanyahu goes, Israel’s war and Palestine policies are unlikely to change

Talks under former army chief Gadi Eisenkot may reshape Israel's domestic politics, but analysts see little shift on Palestinian statehood or settlements.

Crowd waving Israeli flags at an election-period rally in Tel Aviv

Written by

in

International

Even as debate intensifies over the end of caretaker Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s era in Israeli politics, analysts see little prospect of a fundamental shift in Israel’s war and Palestine policies. Although talks to form a new coalition government led by former army chief Gadi Eisenkot have gathered pace, most senior figures in his bloc oppose a Palestinian state and firmly back illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank.

An Al Jazeera analysis notes that Netanyahu’s departure could bring limited domestic political changes, yet Israel’s mainstream parties share largely identical positions on military occupation and regional aggression.

Opposition agenda confined to domestic reforms

Internationally, Eisenkot’s coalition is viewed as somewhat more moderate than Netanyahu’s far-right government, largely because the bloc has pledged to repeal Netanyahu’s controversial judicial overhaul legislation. It has also promised a state commission of inquiry into Israeli security failings ahead of Hamas’s 7 October 2023 attack, alongside ending ultra-Orthodox draft exemptions in line with a 2024 Supreme Court ruling.

Beyond these domestic measures, however, the coalition’s foreign and security posture differs little from Netanyahu’s.

Where the coalition’s top leaders stand

Among the five leading figures in the opposition bloc vying to form a government, only Yair Golan, head of the left-wing party The Democrats, holds a more liberal stance. The other four influential leaders remain hardline on Palestine:

Gadi Eisenkot: Leader of the Yashar Party and former military chief of staff, Eisenkot strongly opposes an independent Palestinian state and explicitly backs maintaining existing illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank. He has broadly supported the war on Gaza, which has killed more than 74,600 Palestinians, as well as attacks on neighbouring states including the ongoing war on Iran. Eisenkot is the architect of Israel’s controversial ‘Dahiya doctrine’, which calls for overwhelming force against civilian areas, and argued in March that the doctrine should again be used in Lebanon.

Naftali Bennett: The B’Yachad Party leader previously headed a settlers’ council in the occupied West Bank. He opposes a Palestinian state and has favoured annexing 60 percent of the West Bank. In October 2023, he also defended cutting off water and electricity to Gaza.

Avigdor Lieberman: Head of the secular right-wing Yisrael Beiteinu party, Lieberman has been vocal in backing the expansion of illegal settlements in the West Bank. In December 2023 during the Gaza war, he drew controversy by declaring there were ‘no innocents in Gaza’.

Yair Lapid: Bennett’s B’Yachad Party partner backs a two-state solution in the long term, though without concrete details.

‘The problem was never just Netanyahu’

Analysts say Israeli society has shifted steadily to the right since 7 October 2023. Israel currently maintains military occupation over roughly 7,252 square kilometres of Palestinian and Syrian territory and governs around 5.5 million Palestinians who have no vote.

H A Hellyer of the UK’s Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) told Al Jazeera: ‘Many people have pinned their hopes on Netanyahu leaving, imagining that a moderate or even progressive government would follow. But the problem was never just Netanyahu. His absence would only expose how far the rest of the Israeli political spectrum, including much of the opposition, shares the same positions on occupation and Palestinian rights.’

He added that it would take years before Israeli leaders and the public accept withdrawing from Gaza, the occupied West Bank, Syria or southern Lebanon.

বাংলায় মূল প্রতিবেদন পড়ুন · Read the original Bengali report

More in English

English edition