AI seeks fatwas in the digital age: Can technology deepen confusion?

People are increasingly asking AI tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini for religious guidance, but experts warn that confident answers may be incomplete, context-blind or wrong.

Abstract digital illustration representing artificial intelligence

Written by

in

Islamic

People are increasingly turning to smartphones to solve everyday problems. Alongside ordinary information, many now ask artificial intelligence tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini for religious guidance on prayer, fasting, zakat and complicated family matters instead of consulting a mosque imam or an experienced scholar.

The tools produce polished answers in seconds, but their easy availability raises a larger question: are they guiding people toward the right path or pushing them deeper into confusion? A recent international study highlighted the limits of AI. Omar Amer, a researcher at the Franco-Arab University of Africa in Mali, posed 30 religious and contemporary questions to popular AI models. The results showed that although the models answered confidently, most responses were incomplete, irrelevant or filled with inaccurate information.

Why experts see risks in AI answers

Analysts and theologians say there is a fundamental difference between human understanding of life and a machine’s algorithm. They identify several reasons AI-generated religious guidance can be dangerous.

The risk of overconfidence and misinformation

When a person or a learned scholar is unsure about something, they can openly acknowledge that they do not know. AI, however, can present incorrect or incomplete information in definitive and appealing language, leading ordinary users to assume that it is accurate.

Inability to understand reality and context

Solutions do not depend only on rules written in books. They can change according to the questioner’s age, circumstances and mental state. A machine can read words on a screen, but it cannot understand the complex realities of a person’s life.

Unclear sources and uncertain reliability

AI assembles answers from large amounts of unverified information of varying quality scattered across the internet. That makes it difficult for ordinary users to determine the original source of a claim or how reliable it is.

Lack of accountability

A wrong recommendation or decision can cause serious personal or family harm. People carry moral and social responsibility for their advice; a machine has no feelings or accountability.

Technology and experience: Where is the balance?

Experts do not argue for rejecting technology altogether. Leading religious research institutions in countries such as Jordan and Egypt say AI can be useful as an assistant that speeds the work of researchers and scholars, rather than as a direct decision-maker for the public. It can save time by quickly finding references in large bodies of material and handling calculations.

Experts advise people to treat any sensitive information generated by technology as an initial reference, not a final decision. On important and delicate matters, seeking direct advice from an experienced specialist is safer than relying on a machine’s algorithm.

বাংলায় মূল প্রতিবেদন পড়ুন · Read the original Bengali report

More in English

English edition